Jump to content

Stop letting people get away with comparing individual European Countries to the US when comparing statistics about shootings. That's not even close to an equivalent comparison.

Recommended Posts

This comparison needs to stop happening.
It's a problem on both ends of the debate as well.
We're not really number eleven as seen here if you actually look at the year to year statistics instead of the mean. Year to year statistics matter a lot more in a comparison like this one. Norway is on top of that list because of a single incident and because of a huge population difference.
It's data manipulation and not a good faith argument.
We need to make a more accurate and honest comparison and stop letting people get away with this inaccurate comparison.
We simply shouldn't be putting up with comparing Norway, France, Germany, or any other European country to the entire US. This is also true of other favorite comparison nations such as Japan, Australia, etc...
The US as an entity, in the context of how it matters to these kinds of statistics, is more like the entirety of Europe than any individual European country.
The US has far more shootings than Norway. It's a simple fact. However, it's an irrelevant comparison that only implies that the US has some absurd number of shootings compared to the rest of the world if you take it completely out of context and at face value.
It is far more accurate to compare individual European countries to individual US States such as California or Texas. Because that is a much more accurate equivalent comparison in every metric that matters here.
States in the US are very much like EU countries. They have their own laws, tax systems, court systems, law enforcement, militaries [National Guard], Governors, equivalent populations and economies, and even individual cultures. The main difference is that US States aren't independently sovereign.
It is disingenuous and dishonest to compare the shooting rates of Norway against the shooting rates for the entirety of the US. It would be far more accurate to compare Norway to Maryland or South Carolina rather than the entire US.
Letting people get away with comparing us to individual European countries for these statistics is a bit like comparing the murder rates in Orlando Florida with the murder rates across the entirety of California, or comparing the cheese production of Dusseldorf with that of all of France, and calling it an equivalent comparison. It needs to stop being treated as a valid comparison at all and no one should be letting anyone trying to make such a comparison get away with it without calling them out on it.
Well, would you look at that? All of a sudden the US isn't quite so ahead of the world when it comes to gun violence when you make a far more legitimately equivalent comparison.
Funny that.
  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Keeping this site online isn't free, so we need your support! Make a one-time donation or choose one of the recurrent patron options by clicking here.

  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.